Sign up to receive AEE Weekly or
view our latest issue >

Modernize the Grid and Save; Solar Grows in 2012; America's Natural Gas Highway

Advanced Energy Economy // Dec 14, 2012

This is an excerpt from our newsletter, AEE Weekly. If you would like to receive AEE Weekly, send an email to contact@aee.net.

The Council of State Governments passed a resolution to support the modernization of America’s electrical grid for efficiency benefits while RGGI states met to adjust their trading system. Clean Energy Fuels completed phase one of America’s Natural Gas Highway and SolarCity delayed its IPO before going ahead at a lower price. Johnson Controls declared that it still wants the assets of A123 Systems if the U.S. government denies approval for the sale of those assets to a Chinese company.

 
 
 

STATE GOVERNMENT GROUP LINKS GRID UPGRADES WITH EFFICIENCY

At its annual conference in Austin, Texas, earlier this month, the Council of State Governments passed a resolution supporting efforts to modernize the electric distribution system with advanced meters and other technologies, and encouraging states to count reductions in energy use associated with these grid technologies toward state energy efficiency requirements.

Often states and utilities see distribution system investments and energy efficiency initiatives as distinct and unrelated to each other. Distribution upgrades are performed principally to improve reliability, and investments justified on this basis add to the utilities’ rate base, making them money. Energy efficiency investments, though paid for through electric rates, reduce utilities’ electricity sales and therefore revenue, creating a clash of incentives best resolved through rate mechanisms like decoupling. Advanced meters have been a particular sticking point in some jurisdictions, where system-wide replacement of meters is a costly proposition but the savings from their use has been hard to justify to state regulators (especially where utilities have already put in meters that eliminate the need for meter readers, which reap substantial savings).

But the CSG resolution draws a direct link between grid technology upgrades and a variety of customer benefits. These include “significant savings through reduced utility operational costs, reduced energy theft, and more efficient use of the electric grid” as well as “improved outage prevention, detection and restoration services,” but also reduced energy use.

Advanced meters “provide consumers with more detailed information” on their energy use, enabling them to “better manage their electric consumption and budgets,” according to the CSG. The resolution also cites other grid improvements, such as voltage optimization, that “deliver substantial, immediate, highly predicable, cost-effective, and verifiable energy and demand reduction benefits” without investment or change in behavior on the customer’s part.

On the basis of this link between grid upgrades and efficiency, the CSG “encourages states to continue to evaluate the energy efficiency and demand reduction opportunities that can be achieved with electric utility grid modernization efforts,” subject to local conditions, and to “work with” authorities such as governor, legislature, and public utility commissions to “certify energy efficiency and demand reductions associated with electric utility grid modernization efforts . . . as qualified resources” under their state’s Energy Efficiency Resource Standards, including triggering any rate recovery mechanisms designed to ensure that utilities “are not financially burdened” by the resulting reduction in demand.

As one of two national organizations of state lawmakers (the other being the National Conference of State Legislatures), the CSG helps legislators share and benefit from best practices across states. Through resolutions like this one, the membership of CSG indicates a broad level of support for particular policy approaches and directs CSG staff to spread the word. Indeed, the resolution itself declares that CSG “intends to assist its members and states to take the actions above by creating educational forums on the use of electric utility grid modernization technologies to achieve energy efficiency and demand reduction benefits, and to convene meetings with the associations of governors, state electric utility commissioners, state energy officials, and other parties” to promote the requisite rules and policies to make grid technology an integral part of state energy efficiency efforts.

 
 
 

NEWS OF THE WEEK

The nine member states of the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) met this week to discuss overhauling the nation’s first emissions trading program. Despite expectations that the Northeast states’ power plant emissions program would lower the emissions limit, no decisions will become public for at least another month, according to the Connecticut Mirror. With electricity generation shifting to natural gas based on price, emissions have dropped far below the current cap, reducing the value of allowances sold at auction and the revenue they produce for states, most of which goes into energy efficiency and renewable energy.

Solar energy had mixed news this week with the release of SEIA’s Q3 report, which was encouraging, and SolarCity’s IPO, which had a hiccup. The American photovoltaic market grew by 2 GW in the first three quarters of 2012, with continued growth expected in the fourth quarter. Meanwhile, SolarCity, which had expected to trade between $13 and $15 per share when it first announced its plans to go public, put off its IPO one day, then cut its offer price to $8 per share, thereby raising $92 million. But in the first day of trading, the stock closed much higher, at $11.79.

“I still think this would have been a very good deal at $15,” SolarCity CEO Lyndon Rive told the New York Times Dealbook. “But there was a lot of demand at $8.”

This week saw a judge approve sale of most of the assets from bankrupt A123 Systems to Wanxiang Group. Despite that decision, Johnson Controls noted that it is still interested in purchasing A123’s assets if the U.S. government does not approve Wanxiang’s purchase. A final decision from the Committee for Foreign Investment in the United States could come as late as January. The Chinese firm more than doubled Johnson Controls’ initial bid in the bankruptcy auction.

"We're still interested in this if the sale doesn't work out because of [the failure to get] regulatory approval," Alex Molinaroli, president of Johnson Controls power solutions business, said. "I don't believe this is done yet."

Meanwhile, Clean Energy Fuels completed the first phase of America’s Natural Gas Highway, installing 70 fueling stations along heavily trafficked corridors, and Forbes was first out of the gate with a year-end wrap up, listing its top five energy stories for 2012. AEE Weekly will take its look-back next week.